The United States faced another setback reminiscent of Copa America, losing 1-0 to Panama in the Concacaf Nations League semifinals. This defeat means the competition will crown a new champion for the first time. Despite creating opportunities, the USMNT struggled against a resilient Panama team. While some difficulties were anticipated due to injuries limiting the full USMNT player pool, concerns about squad depth remain as the team progresses towards the 2026 World Cup.
The USMNT employed an unusual starting lineup in this match, with Yunus Musah playing as a right wing-back. Here’s a position-by-position breakdown of player performances.
GK Matt Turner (90 minutes)
Matt Turner was largely untroubled for most of the game, but Cecilio Waterman’s precise shot was virtually unstoppable.
Rating: 5
DEF Joe Scally (90 minutes)
Joe Scally showed promise with overlapping runs alongside Christian Pulisic and Tim Weah on the flanks. However, he wasn’t sharp enough to react to Waterman’s run and shot on goal. Playing out of position at left back, this match highlighted the absence of Antonee Robinson.
Rating: 4
DEF Tim Ream (90 minutes)
Tim Ream delivered another consistent defensive performance. He was solid and reliable, avoiding any critical errors. The USMNT could certainly benefit from a younger player with Ream’s qualities.
Rating: 6
DEF Chris Richards (79 minutes)
Chris Richards struggled with possession at times, requiring Tyler Adams to cover for his mistakes. He was substituted after sustaining an injury while already on a yellow card.
Rating: 5
MID Yunus Musah (90 minutes)
Musah’s versatility might be a double-edged sword. While effective in pressing, his contribution in the final third and delivery into the box could be improved.
Rating: 6
MID Tyler Adams (90 minutes)
The standout player for the USMNT in this match. Adams’ return to the team was crucial, as he consistently intervened to correct errors. Despite the disappointing result, Adams’ presence is a significant positive for the USMNT’s future.
Rating: 7
MID Tanner Tessman (68 minutes)
Tanner Tessman provided a steady presence in midfield, maintaining ball circulation. However, he lacks the incisiveness needed to break down deep-lying defenses. The midfield setup did not particularly suit his strengths.
Rating: 6
MID Weston McKennie (90 minutes)
Weston McKennie positioned himself well and created some opportunities, but failed to convert the chances that came his way. The midfield balance was again a factor, as McKennie is not naturally a number 10 playmaker.
Rating: 6
FWD Christian Pulisic (90 minutes)
Against a deep defensive block, it’s understandable that Christian Pulisic found it challenging to get shots off. However, managing only one shot throughout the entire match is insufficient. When Pulisic struggles to influence the game, the USMNT’s attacking threat diminishes significantly.
Rating: 5
FWD Tim Weah (90 minutes)
Tim Weah worked hard to generate opportunities from the wings, but similar to Pulisic, he needed to be more willing to shoot. Weah, usually known for his shooting from distance, could have tested the Panamanian defense more.
Rating: 6
FWD Josh Sargent (68 minutes)
This match was a significant opportunity for Josh Sargent to solidify his claim as the starting striker. However, he only touched the ball eight times and his single shot hit the post. While the USMNT’s overall struggle to penetrate Panama’s defense wasn’t solely Sargent’s fault, he needed more support and involvement.
Rating: 6
Substitutes
MID Jack McGlynn: McGlynn came off the bench and distributed passes effectively, injecting a different dimension into the midfield. (22 minutes; Rating: 6)
FWD Patrick Agyemang: Agyemang could have had a memorable night, receiving two chances to potentially win the game. He made a positive impact but needs to convert these opportunities to climb the striker ranks. (22 minutes; Rating: 5)
DEF Mark McKenzie: McKenzie entered the game late, replacing Richards, and had limited time to make a significant contribution. (22 minutes; Rating 5)
