As the football world braces for the unveiling of the 2025 Ballon d`Or shortlist, the familiar hum of debate grows louder. This isn`t merely about who scored the most goals or won the most trophies; it`s an intricate dance between individual brilliance and collective triumph, a perpetual question of `art versus science` that captivates fans and frustrates pundits alike.
The Enduring Dilemma: Stats vs. Silverware
The criteria for the Ballon d`Or, covering achievements from August 1, 2024, to July 31, 2025, seem straightforward enough on paper. Yet, the real complexity lies in interpretation. Is the world`s best player the one who notches eye-watering statistics, irrespective of their team`s ultimate success? Or is it the pivotal figure in a trophy-winning side, even if their personal metrics are less flamboyant? This philosophical divide makes every year`s nominations a subject of intense scrutiny.
In football, where collective effort defines victory, identifying a single “best” individual is inherently subjective. It’s akin to picking the most beautiful note in a symphony; necessary for the whole, but perhaps not the star of every movement.
The Men`s Race: A Trio of Contenders with Divergent Paths
Mohamed Salah: The Statistical Marvel
Leading many early predictions, Liverpool`s Mohamed Salah has once again showcased an astonishing individual campaign. His 34 goals and 23 assists during the 2024-25 season are not just impressive numbers; they were the engine behind Liverpool`s unexpected charge to a league title. Yet, his front-runner status remains contentious for some. Critics point to his influence perhaps peaking earlier in the season, or the absence of a Champions League crown. The argument, however, is hard to dismiss when confronted with such a prolific output, especially when matching Premier League records set in longer seasons. Salah represents the pure, unadulterated individual output argument.
Raphinha: Barcelona`s Resurgent Catalyst
Another player defying pre-season expectations is Barcelona`s Raphinha. Matching Cristiano Ronaldo`s record of 21 goal contributions in a Champions League season is no minor feat; it`s a statement. As arguably the best player in La Liga for the season, Raphinha`s case is compelling. He bridges the gap between individual brilliance and team success, but the burgeoning talent of teammate Lamine Yamal could ironically dilute the Barcelona vote, a peculiar side effect of shared success.
Ousmane Dembele: The Champion`s Choice
If medals and major trophies are the ultimate arbiters, then Paris Saint-Germain`s Ousmane Dembele sits comfortably. As the brightest star in PSG`s Champions League triumph, Dembele embodies the “rings and medals” philosophy. While his raw statistics might not rival Salah`s, his impact on the grandest stage, culminating in European glory, offers a powerful counter-narrative. For many voters, this tangible success outweighs individual tallies, proving that sometimes, the most valuable player is the one who delivers when it counts most.
The Women`s Battlefield: Established Queens and Rising Stars
The women`s Ballon d`Or presents a similarly fascinating dynamic. Aitana Bonmati and Alexia Putellas, both Barcelona stalwarts, remain formidable contenders, having redefined excellence in women`s football for years. However, their team`s defeat in critical matches opens the door for others. Could Arsenal`s English internationals, such as Alessia Russo or Leah Williamson, ascend to the top if their Champions League or Euros final performances are weighed more heavily? The debate here mirrors the men`s: does consistent, long-term dominance trump a decisive impact in a single, high-stakes final?
Moreover, the increased visibility of NWSL stars, like Gotham FC`s Esther Gonzalez and Ann-Katrin Berger, and Orlando Pride`s Barbra Banda and Temwa Chawinga from KC Current, showcases the global depth of talent. Their inclusion in top contender lists highlights the diverse footballing landscapes that now contribute to the highest echelons of the sport.
Beyond the Crown Jewel: Goalkeepers, Coaches, and Clubs
While the Ballon d`Or dominates headlines, the Yashin Trophy for best goalkeeper, and awards for coaches and clubs, offer deeper insights into the year`s standout performers. Gianluigi Donnarumma of PSG and Ann-Katrin Berger of Gotham FC are strong contenders for the goalkeeping honors, reflecting their crucial roles in their respective teams` successes. On the sidelines, Luis Enrique`s tactical prowess with PSG and Sarina Wiegman`s continued excellence with England are recognized, affirming that leadership is as vital as individual skill. Finally, Paris Saint-Germain and Orlando Pride are tipped as the Club of the Year winners, underlining their overall dominance and consistency across the season.
The Verdict: More Art Than Science
Ultimately, the Ballon d`Or is less a precise scientific calculation and more an artistic interpretation. It`s an annual exercise in collective subjectivity, where 100 journalists from leading football nations attempt to quantify the unquantifiable. The debates, the passionate arguments, and yes, the occasional “sulking” from those whose favorites aren`t recognized, are all part of the allure. It’s a reminder that even in a sport obsessed with data, the human element of judgment, preference, and the sheer joy of watching extraordinary talent, will always prevail. As the envelopes are unsealed, one thing is certain: the conversation will be far from over.
